Sunday, August 17, 2014

Brazil, the Brazilian Economy and the 1994 World Cup

On July 17th 1994, Brazil won their fourth world cup after beating Italy 3-2 on penalties. The game itself was a forgettable 0-0 draw with few chances, while the penalties are mostly remembered for misses by Italian legends, Franco Baresi and Roberto Baggio.  Most people would say that penalties were a suitable finish to a tournament which is roundly remembered as the least inspiring World Cup of all. Even the final’s ultimate outcome was dull: another World Cup for Brazil? So what?

Actually, it mattered a lot.

Brazil 1994
Brazil was at a historical low-ebb in 1994. Far from the image people have of them being fun-loving happy types, Brazilians were miserable. In their 1970 world cup song, they happily sung about reaching a population of 90 million. By 1994, the population had spiked to 155 million and nobody was singing about it. A third of the population was living below the poverty line.

The country was an economic basket case where hyper-inflation was running at close to 3,000% a year. These days, people recall how they would take their wage packet straight to the local supermarket to stock up on non-perishables as their money would be near worthless a month later. Private savings in banks had recently been seized by the government and earnings were being taxed at over 50%.

In politics, it was less than two years since their first democratically elected President since 1960 had been impeached for corruption. President Fernando Collor had been voted in on the strength of big promises to turn around Brazil’s faltering economy. Instead, he brought hyper-inflation and graft. His successor, who came to power without an election, was Itamar Franco. Six months into his presidential term, a poll showed that less than 50% of Brazilians knew who he was.

In the excellent and emotive 2011 documentary, Senna, one woman best captures the feeling prevalent in Brazil at the time: “There is nothing good in Brazil but Ayrton Senna.”

And then Ayrton Senna died.

Obituaries don’t do justice to what Ayrton Senna meant to Brazilians. Too often, sports stars are said to have transcended their sport but in Senna’s case, it was almost certainly true. It’s difficult to think of a British equivalent. After his death on May 1st 1994, Brazil had three days of national mourning. News channels devoted an entire day to covering the funeral which attracted over a million people. Brazilians weeped openly on national television. Brazil wasn’t just an economic wreck - It was an emotional wreck.

Ayrton Senna: Quite popular in Brazil, actually.

Carlos Alberto Parreira
In Brazil, when you’re coach of the national football team, your job is to win the World Cup. The Confederations Cup, the Olympic Games and the Copa America are window dressing. The World Cup is your money-maker. In Brazil, it is known simply as “a copa” (the cup), suggesting an unerring focus on its importance. When Carlos Alberto Parreira was appointed Brazil coach in 1992, it was therefore his role to win the next World Cup being held in the US in 1994.

The position was a perilous one to take on for any coach in 1992. Parreira would be the fourth coach in as many years – a statistic which didn’t bode well for his future. He replaced Falcão (himself a former popular member of the Brazil team) who lasted less than a year on the job, and that after coming a respectable second in the Copa America.

Unlike his predecessor, Parreira hadn’t been a fan’s favourite. Nor was he a particularly experienced coach. What he was able to grasp quickly, however, was that the Brazil team was fractured and had been for a few years. Fighting in camp was to blame for their uninspired showing at the World Cup in 1990. It was considered such a fiasco that Falcão was forbidden from taking any of those players to the Copa America in 1991. Parreira was now calling them back for what everyone hoped would be a grand reunion.

World Cup ´94 Qualifiers
The World Cup qualifiers in the CONEMBOL (South America’s football confederation) group in 1993 are probably best remembered for two events: Colombia defeating Argentina 5-0 and Bolivia beating Brazil 2-0. Incredibly, Brazil had never lost a World Cup qualifier before. Maybe only the hammering of Argentina on the same day as the Bolivia defeat softened the blow to Brazilian fans, taking the spotlight from their faltering national team coach.

Nevertheless, in the following game against Ecuador, online footage shows that fans´ calls for his head were deafening. In a game the Brazilians were expected to win, they managed a dour 0-0 draw. At the centre of the debate was Dunga, a midfield general, untypical of a Brazilian captain. He seemed to epitomize the dour football that Parreira was being accused of; a cog in a 4-4-2 system that was considered more European than Brazilian.

You would think that after 24 years without winning the World Cup (the longest such dry patch in history for Brazil), they’d have been happy to opt for the pragmatism of Parreira in the hope that it might bring success. But Brazilians have a self-proclaimed love affair with jogo bonito, the beautiful game. The 1994 team still isn’t regarded as highly as the 1982 team of Zico and Falcão, despite the failure of the latter team. The reason? Where do you start? For one thing, the 1982 team would never have had a Dunga as captain.

The nation’s rose-tinted glasses for the 1982 team didn’t stop there. Brazil’s right-back during the 1994 qualifying round, Jorginho, explains: “all through the qualifiers there was a real pressure on the confederation to call in Tele Santana (the coach from the 1982 team). The fans wanted to fire Parreira. But he overcame all of it.” There is now a sense that the negativity from outside only served to fortify the links between the squad.

When rumours began circulating that the same divisions which had driven apart the 1990 World Cup team were appearing again, the Brazilian team’s joker-in-chief, centre back Ricardo Rocha, suggested they enter the field holding hands in the next game: the return leg against Bolivia in Recife. Commentators laughed it off as a gimmick at the beginning of the match. Nevertheless, it stuck; the team kept doing it before games until the final of the World Cup the following year.

The Bolivia game marked a turnaround in the team’s qualifying campaign. Brazil won the game 6-0. The nucleus of the team that would win the World Cup was also being formed. Taffarel returned after losing his place earlier in the year to Zetti. Parreira only wanted players getting first-team football and Taffarel had been a victim of the 3-foreigners-only rule at Parma. The pragmatic character of the team Parreira was building was exemplified by Taffarel.

Taffarel explains: “There were four foreigners at Parma and only three could be registered. I lost out and my game became very rusty. I turned up for the Copa America in ´93 and lost my place to Zetti, who was playing really well. I moved to a little known-team (Reggiana) so that I could play every weekend. It prepared me really well.” He would have a telling influence on the outcome of the World Cup one year after moving to a club most players wouldn’t have considered joining.

The Return of the Prodigal Son
All through the qualifying campaign, Parreira had resisted calls to bring Romário back into the squad[1]. His first-choice strikers were Edmundo and Bebéto and on occasion, bizarrely, Muller. At every game, Parreira would be confronted by huge banners calling for the striker who at the time was playing under Bobby Robson at PSV. Pragmatism was one thing but Romário’s exclusion seemed strange – even if it was more than likely rooted in his reputation as a divisive figure.

Injuries forced Parreira’s hand for the final qualifier against Uruguay. With Muller and Edmundo both out, he called Romário into the team. In an interview, Jorginho said, “with the arrival of Romário, the pressure on Parreira diminished, but it was still difficult.” The team had to win their last game in order to qualify. The task wasn’t made any easier by the fact that their opponents, Uruguay (in a team which featured legends Enzo Francescoli and Daniel Fonseca), could still qualify.

The day before the game, Romário met Ricardo Rocha and Dunga on the pitch at the Maracanã and said, “I’m going to score two goals tomorrow. Give me a pen and piece of paper and I’ll show you how this game will go.” The game, Romário now recalls, was “the most perfect game of my life… I didn’t think I’d ever play for the national team again. But they needed me. There was no other option; I was their last hope.”

Unfortunately for Uruguay, what followed was the Romário show. Type “Romário Uruguay 1993” into a search engine and marvel. Twenty years on, it is still remembered as one of the virtuoso performances in a Brazil shirt. In front of 101,670 people at the Maracanã, Brazil won the game 2-0 and guaranteed qualification for the World Cup in the United States. Never before had it come down the final game. It took Brazil 72 minutes to break the deadlock but it somehow all seemed worth it.

The Brazilian left-back of the time, Branco, recalls of the Uruguay game: “Romário was magnificent that day. He couldn’t have played better, it was destiny.” Parreira’s take on the game was perhaps less pragmatic than Brazilians had come to expect: “God sent Romário to the Maracanã.” What is certain is that the team had found a striker worthy of a World Cup winning team. And a partnership with Bebéto that was set to devastate.

Beginning USA 94
Despite qualification, Parreira was still bitterly unpopular in the Brazilian media. The calls continued for his head, even during the warm-up games. Jorginho recalls: “He wanted to leave after the friendly against Mexico (a week before the beginning of the World Cup). There was a meeting and the players said that he should go out (to the press) and tell them that he was going nowhere. When the coach has the respect of the team, they unite more and fight as a unit. It was very noble.”

With Parreira still in charge, Brazil were the seeded team in a group containing weak Cameroon and Russia teams and the Sweden team that would go on to gain a third place medal. After their 1990 exploits, people expected Cameroon to provide a repeat performance. Roger Milla, 38 in 1990, was now 42 and looked older than the Cameroon coach. However, they were dreadful. They were beaten in all three games, including a 6-1 trashing by Russia.

Brazil disposed of both teams with relative ease. They won the Russia game 2-0 with goals from Romário and Rai. They followed that up by beating Cameroon 3-0 with goals from Romário, Bebéto and Márcio Santos. Neither game was greeted with much enthusiasm in Brazil but at least the team was finding its gears. The Sweden game was a somewhat different proposition, even though the team had already qualified for the second round.

The Swedish team contained household names like Thomas Ravelli, Kennet Andersen, Stefan Schwarz, a svelte Tomas Brolin and Martin Dahlin. As it happened, Brolin was one of the three foreigners responsible for keeping Taffarel out of the Parma team. Sweden went ahead early in the game through a Kennet Andersen strike but Brazil responded (very late on) through Romário. He says: “that was my favourite goal of the tournament;” an unmarked header from a Bebéto cross.

After the game, Brazil’s newly elected President, Fernando Henrique Cardoso, personally called Parreira to complain about the performance. Pelé was expressing his disappointment with Parreira’s “defensive set-up” and even Parreira’s mother called the national television network about his changing the original lineup of his team. On the positive side, the supposedly dour tactics were at least taking people’s minds away from hyper-inflation and the death of a national icon.

Independence Day
Bebéto says, “The most difficult game was the one where we were most close to a disaster – the game against the United States. They were coming from relatively positive results, they were very aggressive, they were playing at home and it was July 4th, their independence day.” Perhaps subdued by the Sweden result and once again doubting their abilities, Brazil entered the game under a cloud of uncertainty.

Early on in the game, left-back Leonardo was sent off for elbowing the American, Tab Ramos. Both players tussled for a fairly innocuous ball at the left touchline half-way inside Brazil’s half. Leonardo swung an elbow and connected with Ramos’ jaw. The otherwise forgettable player will forever be remembered in Brazil as the man who nearly ended their World Cup in 1994: “The game was tough. After the expulsion of Leonardo, nobody knew what would happen.”

The game was on a knife-edge at 0-0 at half-time and the Americans, playing on their home patch, must have fancied their chances. Bebéto went to the dressing room after the first half ended and found Leonardo there, still in his kit, under the shower and crying. “He kept saying that he was responsible for Brazil getting eliminated from the World Cup.”

Thankfully for Leonardo, Brazil found an edge through Romário and Bebéto late in the second half. A defence-splitting pass from Romário on the right flank found Bebéto in the centre, who slid the ball past American keeper Tony Meola. Brazil had won, if not exactly emphatically. After the game, Jorginho and Bebéto dropped to their knees and hugged each other. It had been that close.

Quarter Finals
Brazil had to face an adept Holland side in the quarter-finals. Holland had easily disposed of the Republic of Ireland in the second round and on paper at least, posed a far greater threat than the Americans in the previous round. Perhaps the American game had stirred them, perhaps the lack of Leonardo was instrumental, but Brazil dealt very easily with Holland.

“We were far superior to Holland in every aspect, from what I remember,” muses Jorginho. They were, but they didn’t take the lead until the second half. Romário scored with a deft touch from a Bebéto cross seven minutes after the restart. This was soon followed by a mix-up in the Dutch defence, leaving Bebéto to round goalkeeper Ed de Goey and do that celebration.

Holland did strike back to make it 2-2 but almost nobody remembers that. Bergkamp scored from close range and Aaron Winter equalized with a nice header which had been typically badly defended. For the Brazilians that believe in destiny – and there are literally millions of them – this was perhaps the moment in the tournament when destiny played her hand.

Leonardo’s replacement at left-back, Branco, cut inside a couple of Dutch players a little past the half-way point of the opposition half. They fouled him, despite there being no immediate danger. Dunga, also a free-kick expert, seemed to fancy it. A little bit off centre and a good distance out, it was in both their ranges. But Branco had won it and he wanted to take it.

3-2 Brazil.

The free-kick swerved slightly to the left of the wall through a muddle of bodies and into the bottom left-hand corner of Ed de Goey’s goal. The goal seemed to epitomize everything about that Brazil team: the return of a much-maligned player making a telling contribution at an opportune time. The in-fighting of 1990 was long gone and Brazil were just two games from the copa.

Brazil’s Reserve Team
It is sometimes said that Brazil’s abundance of talent is such that their second string side could win the World Cup. In 1994, that was almost literally what transpired. The team seemed to be suffering from an injury curse that only Abou Diaby could empathize with. It continued right up to the game with Holland when Jorginho had to be stretchered off and replaced by Cafú.

Brazil’s team captain had initially been centre back Ricardo Gomes, but he was injured in the training camp and Márcio Santos was drafted in. Next, Ricardo Rocha was injured in the group stage and was replaced by Aldair. Branco replacing Leonardo at left-back, followed by Cafú at right back meant that the back four that finished was completely different to that which begun the tournament.

Add these changes to the sudden inclusion of Romário and Mauro Silva, and Brazil’s first team complexion is dramatically different to how it might have been. Parreira seems to have been able to instil a sort of doggedness in the team that was missing from previous years though and they’d need it against a resurgent Swedish team in the semi-final that followed.

Semi Final
Sweden came into the semi-final against Brazil having comfortably knocked out crowd-pleasers Romania with a worked free-kick that has yet to be rivaled. Tomas Brolin peeled off the wall and it was just a matter of passing it to him in the six-yard area where he struck it past the open-mouthed Romanian keeper. They weren’t short on confidence, let’s put it that way.

But Brazil totally dominated. In the end, the game was a nothing contest and 1-0 victory to Brazil after another Romário header flattered Sweden. The Swedes in turn would go on to hammer Bulgaria 4-0 in a game, which made people wonder what was the point of the third-fourth playoff and leave a bitter taste in the mouth about Stoichkov, Letchkov and co. But that wasn’t important. Only one thing mattered.

Brazil were in the World Cup final for the first time since 1970.

The Winners Tell History
The 1994 Brazil World Cup Team have reels of amateur video footage thanks to all the camcorders they purchased in American Malls during their five-week stay.[2] The footage can now reveal what went on in the days leading up to the final and underlines how important the victory was to Brazil. Italy may have similar footage. Who knows? To the victors, the spoils.

Two days before the final, the players were given a motivational video: A video showing the 1970 team winning the Jules Rimet trophy. There was no sound on the video and the players watched without talking. At the head of the room sat Parreira’s assistant, Mario Zagallo – the coach of the 1970 team and a legend in Brazil.

Fast forward two days to three hours before the final. Carlos Alberto Parreira tells the players, “you are on the cusp of changing the lives of a generation of Brazilians.” And they were. The unlikely lads that took to the Rose Bowl that day had been abused by the press, booed by fans and written off by Europeans as being “too European.” As it turned out, they were very Brazilian indeed.

Brazil v Italy
Brazil v Italy has a rich history. For one thing, the 1970 final – so eulogized as to have become a parody of itself – was a Brazil v Italy affair. Although truth be told, Italy weren’t eve really in it. In 1982, the second most popular Brazilian team ever (and that, despite conceding a goal to Scotland) was knocked out by the Italy of Paolo Rossi and Marco Tardelli.

In 1994, the roles were reversed, somewhat. Italy were tournament favourites from the outset but had only found their feet after barely making it through the group stage. Roberto Baggio delivered in almost every round. On paper, the squad was as good as Italy have ever had. Pagliuca, Baresi, Maldini, Donadoni, Albertini, Signori and the Baggio’s (Luca and Roberto).

Brazil’s video footage shows them going through how they were going to stop Donadoni. Donadoni! Maybe the thinking was that Baggio couldn’t be stopped so the best way to deal with him was to cut out balls to him at source.

Everyone knows the final and it’s not remembered fondly: “the dullest final ever,” they call it. Pagliuca dropped a shot against the post and then kissed it; Viola attempted a bicycle kick and nearly succeeded. Such are the margins in football – you can be the first man to win a World Cup final with a bicycle kick or you can be Viola. Viola is now a footnote in a game that went to penalties.

Spoiler alert: Brazil eventually won the 1994 World Cup.
“I had never taken penalties before. In my mind, they didn’t count as goals,” Romário

The irony of Romário’s statement is never had penalties mattered so much to Brazil. They won the shootout 3-2 thanks to misses from Baresi and Baggio and a save from Taffarel. The Brazilian keeper was the man everyone jumped on at the end. The one who couldn’t get a game at Parma and had been loaned to Reggiana had just beaten a team full of Parma, Milan and Juventus players.

Carlos Alberto Parreira had been a physiotherapist for the 1970 team and had now come full circle. On the victory, he remarked: "The victory was the effort of all the players who gave it their all for two months, sacrificing to practice, play and win," Parreira said. "I dedicate the victory to all the people in Brazil in general, to those who have suffered.”
“Although most of the Brazilian and international press were always criticizing my philosophy, I stuck by my ideas and principles," he said. "It feels great because, like Frank Sinatra said in that song, I did it my way." Parreira didn’t acknowledge the role fate had played with injuries but maybe it was a day for bathing in it.
That same day, Bebéto told journalists: "The economics and financial picture in Brazil is sad. I hope this victory will stimulate the government to improve the economic conditions. The lack of jobs and the poor children are a very big problem. We were a team on a mission." They achieved their mission and played whatever part footballers can in the recovery of a nation.
Aftermath
In April 1994, with inflation running at an annual 2,500%, Brazilian President Fernando Henrique Cardoso put the “Real Plan” into operation. The plan created a new currency, the real, which would be pegged to the dollar. In 1995, inflation fell to 15%. With help from the IMF and an operable plan for economic stability in place, Brazil began to get its ship in order.
Brazil won the World Cup again in 2002 after a gap of only 8 years. The Brazilian economy is slowing but is now the fifth biggest in the world. Poverty has fallen by over 50% since 1994 and inflation is around 6%. The days of waiting 24 years for a World Cup, immense poverty and inflation are hopefully gone and not to return to Brazil.
The significance of the result seems even more important with hindsight. Looking back, Bebéto says: “We wanted to bring happiness to the people. The country had just lost Ayrton Senna. We thought of the suffering the people were going through and knew we couldn’t mess up. We had to give everything.”

Reports on the first game




[1] They were also calling for the inclusion young Ronaldo, then 17 (and incidentally, called Ronaldinho (“little Ronaldo”) as there was already a Ronaldo in the squad at the time, the centre back Ronaldão, or “big Ronaldo”) but the calls for Romário were much louder.
[2] A TV Globo report released on the day the team arrived in Brazil showed that they needed five shipping containers for all the shopping the Brazilian squad had undertaken while in the US. Among the purchases was a fridge and three large-screen televisions.

No comments:

Post a Comment